Strain the drink into a cocktail glass. Garnish with a berry and peanut butter if desired (or a tiny P&J: you choose!). The most famous peanut butter whiskey drink? The Peanut Butter and Jelly! This quirky sweet tart cocktail pairs Skrewball peanut butter and cranberry juice to make a drink version of your favorite childhood sandwich! We took inspiration from the co-founder of Skrewball herself, Brittany Yeng, who recommends.