It can also be caught in Winter if a Rain Totem is used. 19 mai 2022 · The best location to catch a walleye is the Cindersap Forest Pond, where if you are casting during rainy fall days you have a 32% chance of having a walleye on your line. Since walleyes can be difficult to find, it’s a good idea to maximize your chances of successfully reeling them the first time around.